Friday, February 3, 2012

Major Development in Cariou v. Prince from Image-Licensing Giants Corbis and Getty

In the closely watched copyright brawl between appropriation artist Richard Prince and photographer Patrick Cariou now playing out in the federal appellate court in Manhattan, trade associations representing photo-licensing giants Corbis and Getty Images and 7000 photographers have submitted a "friend of the court" brief in support of Cariou.

Read my latest story on the Cariou v. Prince case in The Art Newspaper, here.

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Sacre Bleu! Featured Fragonard Fails at Christie's, as Do Memling and Arcimboldo

Giambattista Tiepolo oil sketch, one of the few high points of Christie's Old Masters sale
How will the Christie's publicity machine spin this?

The morning Old Masters sale had few enough high points, though a sparkling Giambattista Tiepolo oil sketch sold for $5.2 million (the highest of the day's sales), about mid-estimate, and a splendid Thomas de Keyser portrait, selling for $1.25 million, left its $500,000 high estimate in the dust.

But the afternoon sale, which broke out the French works, was abysmal, with nearly half the works unsold -- among them the catalogue cover, Fragonard's "The Good Mother."  It was expected to reach $5 to $7 million but the bidding died at $4.2 million. 

Memling's "Virgin Mary Nursing the Christ Child" and a painting attributed to Arcimboldo were among the spectacular flops in the morning sale.

The Memling had an estimate of $6 to $8 million, but the $5.5 million high bid evidently didn't reach the reserve.  The Arcimboldo may have been done in by doubts about its attribution (see the post immediately preceding).

Remember the Pieter Molijn that the Getty Museum restituted to the heirs of Jewish art dealer Jacques Goudstikker last March?  For all the publicity then, no sale today.

Update:  Well, the Christie's press release is out, and there's a bit of good news:  The Thomas de Keyser was purchased by the National Gallery, so one of the loveliest paintings in the sale (see photo in preceding post) should before too long be on public view.

Photo and text Copyright 2012 Laura Gilbert

Saturday, January 21, 2012

Christie's Old Masters Preview: The Ones to Watch

Memling, Virgin Mary Nursing the Christ Child
A painting stolen for Nazi war criminal Hermann Goering, one of the few Memlings still in private hands, and a work that might or might not be by the strange Arcimboldo are among the offerings at Christie's Old Masters auction next week.  The highlights:

Hans Memling, Virgin Mary Nursing the Christ Child.  One of the few paintings by the great 15th-century Netherlandish artist remaining in private hands, this tiny devotional image (less than 7 inches in diameter) has an archaic gold ground but also the sweet delicacy one expects from Memling, and masterful detail.

Estimate: $6-$8 million (the highest in the sale), with a third-party guarantee.

Tiepolo, Arrival of Henry III
Giambattista Tiepolo, Arrival of Henry III at the Villa Contarini.  This large, 28-by-42-inch oil sketch for the fresco decoration of the Villa Pisani has a provenance more interesting than the event depicted (the French king stopped there once).  First recorded in the possession of a friend of Tiepolo, it was later owned by the Rothschild family, then seized by the Nazis for Hermann Goering.  After the war, it was recovered by the Monuments Men, returned to France, and restituted to the Rothschilds.

Estimate:  $4-$6 million, and perhaps worth every penny -- it's darn good-looking, with sophisticated color, and the fresco, according to the catalogue, is a wreck.

Fragonard, The Good Mother.  Probably better known for his playful erotic scenes, the Rococo artist was also a master at landscape and genre painting, which this work shows off magnificently.  It appears to be in pristine condition.


Estimate:  $5-$7 million.

Giuseppe Arcimboldo, Anthropomorphic Portrait of a Man.  It's a bit much to call this a "portrait" rather than, say, a "face."  Is it also a bit much to call it an Arcimboldo?

It was sold in 1999 as "manner of Giuseppe Arcimboldo" and flipped the next year at Sotheby's as autograph.  Of the latter, connoisseur and dealer Richard Feigen wrote in the September 2008 Art Newspaper, "A painting attributed to the rare painter, Arcimboldo, was sold at Sotheby's, New York, for $1.5m.  It has never been accepted as by Arcimboldo himself."  Christie's catalogue calls the attribution "secure."  What will the market think?

Estimate:  $3-$5 million.

Gerrit Dou, Young Lady Playing a Clavichord.  This painting is alone reason to welcome auctions -- for a few days there's a chance to see a major work that had been "whereabouts unknown for generations," says the catalogue.  It turns out to have been owned by the same family for almost a century but apparently not exhibited (or cleaned) during that time.

Dou, a Dutch master of the small work, last year got a record $5-million-plus at Sotheby's.  Estimate: $1-$2 million.

Thomas de Keyser, Portrait of a Gentleman.  Judging from this 1627 portrait, de Keyser should be a household name despite the missing flecks of paint and the clouded areas at the bottom and the right.  The face and ruff -- gorgeous.  Estimate: $300,000-$500,000.


A couple of others to watch: a wonderful oil sketch, newly discovered, of The Assumption of the Virgin by the incomparable Rubens (left, estimate: $2-$3 million) and a 1756 double portrait of children by Francois Hubert Drouais (below, estimate: $1.2-$1.8 million).  Then there's a passel of works by Pieter Breughel the Younger -- landscape and fables copied from his father's work.


Christie's at Rockefeller Center, viewing January 21-24, sale January 25.

Image of Dou, from Christie's catalogue.

Other photographs and text Copyright 2012 Laura Gilbert.

Tuesday, January 10, 2012

Italy Caves on Restitution, Defaults After U.S. Seizes Painting in Florida


"Christ Bearing the Cross Dragged by a Rascal" by Girolamo de' Romano ("Romanino")

A federal court in Florida last week cleared the way for the heirs of a Jewish art collector to take possession of a painting that, according to the U.S. government’s complaint, had been illegally seized and auctioned by French Vichy authorities in concert with Nazi occupiers in 1941.

The painting, “Christ Bearing the Cross Dragged by a Rascal” by 16th-century artist Girolamo de’ Romano, was in the United States as part of a 50-painting loan from Milan’s Pinacoteca di Brera to the Mary Brogan Museum of Art and Science in Tallahassee, Florida. 

Painting Seized at 11th Hour

On November 4, 2011, a mere two days before the painting was scheduled to return to Milan, the U.S. Attorney’s Office began the federal court action.  That same day, the painting was seized by U.S. Customs and Homeland Security officials amid a blast of media coverage.

Neither the Brera nor the Italian government, which owns the Brera, answered the U.S. government’s complaint, and on January 3 the court entered a default judgment against them.

According to papers filed with the court, the art collector, Federico Gentili di Giuseppe, had amassed a collection of more than 70 works, some of which his heirs have been attempting to recover.  In 1999, a French court ordered the Louvre to return five paintings, and the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, the Art Institute of Chicago, and the Princeton University Art Museum have settled with the heirs, the papers say. 

Schiele's "Portrait of Wally"

The last high-profile painting that was seized by the government off the walls of a museum – first by New York State and then by the Feds -- was Egon Schiele’s “Portrait of Wally,” which was on loan to MoMA from the Leopold Museum in Vienna.  It took 10 years to settle that case.

Seizure was permissible in both instances because MoMA and the Brogan failed to get U.S. State Department certification granting these works immunity from seizure.

The Italian government and the heirs of Gentili di Giuseppe had been in negotiations for some time before the show that included “Christ Bearing the Cross” was due to close, and in July the U.S. Attorney requested the Brogan to keep the painting beyond the show’s end date, until the ownership dispute was resolved.

Reporting on the dispute in October, the New York Times stated that Chucha Barber, the Brogan’s chief executive, hoped that the publicity might bring the museum much needed donors.

No such luck.  The museum will shutter its doors indefinitely on January 15 while it figures out how to become financially viable, according to the Tallahassee Democrat. 

Princeton settled the heirs' claim to Pintoricchio's St. Bartholomew
Images: Top, Wikipedia; bottom, Princeton University Art Museum website

Text Copyright 2012 Laura Gilbert 

Friday, January 6, 2012

They’re Back: Two Small Portraits by Hals Join the Big Boys

Hals, Anna van der Aar, oil on wood, 1626
Two small, magnetic portraits by Frans Hals that have been in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum since 1929 are at last on permanent display.

Hals, Petrus Scriverius
In the museum’s huge, 228-work “Age of Rembrandt” show in 2007, these roughly 9-by-6.5-inch paintings of Petrus Scriverius and his wife, Anna van der Aar, were unexpected standouts – unexpected because they are so darn beautiful yet were hardly ever on view.

At the time, I asked curator Walter Liedke when we might see them again, and he said, “The small works will be back.”   When the Rembrandt show was taken down, though, and the Dutch galleries rehung, these two were nowhere to be seen.

Four years later, they were stars again, this time in Met’s Frans Hals show.

Again I asked Liedke about them, and he said they would soon be on permanent view in a freestanding display case in the Rembrandt-Hals gallery.

And now they are, holding their own among some of the most famous Dutch paintings in the Met’s collection, including Rembrandt’s “Aristotle Contemplating the Bust of Homer.”

The Hals portraits newly installed
The two portraits are on one side of the case.  On the other is a small night scene, "An Evening School," by Gerrit Dou.

Images:  First and second from the Metropolitan Museum website.
Text and third photo Copyright 2012 Laura Gilbert

Monday, January 2, 2012

Taking Stock at Year-End: The Google Search

Richard Prince (left) and Larry Gagosian
As some of you have no doubt noticed, thanks to you my articles published here and elsewhere frequently appear in the top five of Google search results, even months after they are published. 

Today I performed some searches on Google (using Firefox) for rankings of news that I broke and exhibitions that I reviewed.

Cezanne loan nixed
Here are results -- as of this morning -- for some of my top-ranked articles, indicating what words I typed in, the number of results for that search, and who placed above or below me.  I could include more stories but you get the idea, and my gratitude.

Search:  Russian art loan embargo      
Number of Search Results:  1,190,000
Rankings:

            1.  My New York Observer article on Chabad v. Russian Federation, the court case that triggered Russia’s embargo on loaning art to U.S. museums
            2.  Jerusalem Post
            3.  New York Times
            4.  New York Times
            5.  Los Angeles Times

Search: Richard Prince copyright lawsuit
Number of Search Results: 153,000
Rankings:

            1.  New York Times
            2.  My New York Observer article breaking the news of Prince’s strategy on appeal and what happened to his unsold, copyright-infringing paintings
            3.  New York Observer
            4.  New York Times
            5.  New York Times

Soutine portrait
Search:  Soutine Bacon
Number of Search Results: 141,000
Rankings:

            1.  My review of the Soutine/Bacon show held in New York
            2.  New York Times
            3.  Huffington Post

Search:  Metropolitan Museum cancels loans
Number of Search Results:  106,000
Rankings:

            1.  My Observer article breaking the news that the Met had canceled loans to Russia in response to Russia’s art embargo
            2.  New York Times (kindly and appropriately crediting my article with breaking the news)

Search: Picasso Marie Therese lamour fou
Number of Search Results: 17,300
Rankings:

            1.  My review of the "Picasso and Marie-Therese: L’amour fou" show at the Gagosian Gallery
            2.  Gagosian
            3.  Artnet
            4.  nymuseums
            5.  New York Magazine

On loan from Koons
Search:  Jeff Koons Old Masters Metropolitan Museum
Number of Search Results: 39,400
Rankings:

            1.  New York Observer (kindly and appropriately referring to my article, which broke the story)
            2.  My story uncovering Koons’ secret loans of his Old Masters to the Met
            3.  Telegraph

Search:  Poussin fails to sell
Number of Search Results:  3,560,000
Rankings:

            1.  My piece on Poussin’s “Ordination” flopping at Christie’s
            2.  BBC
            3.  Wall Street Journal

Search: Cervera Hebrew Bible Metropolitan Museum
Number of Search Results: 104,000
Rankings:

            1.  My piece on the opening of the Cervera Hebrew Bible display at the Met
            2.  My piece on pages of the Bible showing unicorns in the context of French and Islamic art
           
Search: Richard Prince Larry Gagosian copyright infringement
$2.43 million paid
Number of Results:  7,670
Rankings:

            1.  The Art Newspaper
            2.  My story (different from my Observer article mentioned above) exclusively revealing some of the buyers of Prince’s infringing paintings and how much they paid

Search: Rauschenberg Short Circuit
Number of Search Results: 8,660
Rankings:

            1.  New York Times
            2.  My piece analyzing Robert Rauschenberg’s “Short Circuit”

Search: Passion in Venice Man of Sorrows
Number of Search Results: 292,000
Rankings:

            1.  Museum of Biblical Art
            2.  Amazon
            3.  Wall Street Journal
            4.  New York Times
            5.  My review of the “Passion in Venice” show that examined the Man of Sorrows at New York’s Museum of Biblical Art

Images: Top from Artinfo, Cezanne and Soutine pulled from the internet, bottom image from court documents. 
Image of Koons loan and text Copyright 2011-2012 Laura Gilbert

Friday, December 23, 2011

Restitution Fears, or Lost Opportunity? "Transition to Christianity" at the Onassis Cultural Center and the Absent "David Plates"

Head of Aphrodite, with eyes gouged out and a cross carved into her forehead
Is it fear of a claim for restitution, or just a lost opportunity?

All nine parts of a seminal, 7th-century work -- a masterpiece of Byzantine art -- are now on view in New York, but for reasons unknown they are being displayed at two separate institutions.

The David Plates, a set of nine, various-sized silver plates – magisterially made with a sophisticated understanding of classical sculpture and an intricate attention to detail – cry out to be shown together, as they were some 1,400 years ago.

Detail, David and Goliath plate, at the Met
They depict scenes from the life of the biblical David, and were probably made for the Byzantine emperor Heraclius.  They are commonly included in surveys of what used to be called the “Dark Ages.”

Six of the plates, including the largest (19.5 inches across) and most magnificent, are displayed in a nondescript corridor of the Metropolitan Museum. The other three are now on temporary loan from the Cyprus Museum, and can be seen through May 14 at the Onassis Cultural Center, where they are the culmination of its “Transition to Christianity” exhibit.

Marriage of David, at the Onassis Center
Scholars think the plates were originally displayed in the shape of a symbol that refers to Christ, with the medium and small plates placed around the large one. But for some as-yet-undisclosed reason, this configuration will not be recreated here.

Goodness knows when, if ever, all nine plates be in the same city again.

The plates were discovered in 1902 by laborers looking for building stone in the ruins of the Byzantine town of Lambousa, Cyprus.  The Cypriot authorities confiscated three of them but, the story goes, the others were smuggled out of the country, sold to a Paris dealer, and bought by J.P. Morgan.  Morgan’s heirs donated them to the Met in 1917.

Why aren’t all the pieces of what the Met describes as “exceptionally important” and "a masterwork of Byzantine art" being shown together?  The Met loaned several other items to the Onassis Center show, but the plates didn’t make the 30-block trip south.  The Onassis exhibit’s curator did not respond to inquiries, and no one at the Met was available for comment.

Six David Plates on view in a corridor at the Met
The word from an art history veteran is that Cyprus would like the Met’s plates returned to Cyprus, and it even made some fuss about it in the 1970s.

Derek Fincham, an expert in cultural heritage law, said that Cyprus “probably would not have success on a legal claim” – it would fail on statute of limitations grounds alone, he said -- but it might have an ethical claim to the plates “as an important piece of Cypriot heritage” that it could pursue as a public relations matter.

The Met might not want to loan the plates to the Onassis Center, Fincham suggested, because “the Met wouldn’t want people to make the connection.”

(How and when the plates got to Cyprus is unknown -- because of their high quality, it is thought that they were made in Constantinople -- and if Cyprus were to claim that the Met plates are part of its heritage, further evidence might be needed.)

Personification of April
The David Plates, in any event, could well be Exhibit A in any argument that “dark ages” is a misnomer for describing the 3rd through 7th centuries, and this is one of the themes of “Transition to Christianity.”  It presents this period, under the rubic “late antiquity,” as a time of innovation and change from paganism to Christianity.  The process took centuries, during which the two both coexisted and were in tension, and were sometimes at war.

The crucial figure, of course, was Constantine -- in 313 he established tolerance for Christianity with the Edict of Milan, and in 324-330 he moved the capital from Rome to Constantinople.  Much activity in the visual arts followed the emperors to the East, and in this exhibition it is in the art from the East, mainly Greece, that we follow the cultural changes.

A direct effect of the emperors’ adoption of Christianity -- only one emperor after Constantine was not Christian – is shown in a display of gold coinage.  An image of the emperor consistently appears on the front, but the mythological or historical scenes on the back gradually give way to a cross or an angel.

Mummy portrait, 1st century
Conflict between ideologies is made vivid with the Christianizing of classical sculpture:  a first century head of Aphrodite has her eyes gouged out and a cross carved on her forehead, for example.  Still, the beauty of this sculpture (the photo at the top doesn't do it justice) and a defaced portrait of a Roman boy is breathtaking.

The exhibition is particularly effective in demonstrating that even after Christianity became dominant, its imagery was deeply rooted in Greek and Roman art.  Whether Christian or pagan, the motifs are often the same.  Philosophers of classical art are models for Christian apostles. A man carrying a lamb, a standard motif in pagan bucolic scenes, is the basis of the Good Shepherd trope of Christianity.  The forms of Egyptian mummy portraiture produced under Roman rule, facing front with overlarge eyes, reappear as an icon of Christ’s face.

Icon fragment
The three mummy portraits and the icon are highlights of the show – the former for their beauty and the latter for its rarity.  Most icons on panel, like this one, were destroyed in the 8th-century iconoclastic movement against visual art.

“Transition to Christianity” is an engaging exhibit.  It could have been historic had the David Plates been reunited.

“Transition to Christianity: Art of Late Antiquity, 3rd-7th Century A.D.,” Onassis Cultural Center, 645 Fifth Ave. at 51st St., through May 14.

Addendum:  Four days after my initial inquiry to the Met, asking why all nine David weren't being shown together, its vice president of communications, Elyse Topalian, chose to respond by email.

It stated:  "The six David Plates in the Met's collection have long been scheduled to be highlights of the upcoming exhibition 'Byzantium and Islam: Age of Transition (7th-9th Century),' which will be on view at the Metropolitan Museum from March 14 through July 8, 2012.  Because the exhibitions will overlap for two months, the works of art can't be on view together in a single location.  But these exhibitions do provide a terrific opportunity to see the nine plates, all during one period of time, in New York City."  (Emphasis is mine.)

This seemed to beg the question:  Why couldn't there be a short-term loan between institutions during the two-and-a-half months before the Met show opens?  That's what happened recently at the Bode Museum, which showed Leonardo's "Lady with an Ermine" (as part of the Renaissance portrait show now at the Met) for some weeks before sending it to London to hang in the National Gallery's Leonardo exhibition.

After the holidays, I asked the Onassis Cultural Center's director, Amalia Cosmetatou, if it had asked the Met to lend the plates to its "Transition to Christianity" exhibition.  While not answering the question directly, she said the Met's David Plates were on permanent display there, and that "because of the two exhibits, perhaps it wouldn't have been possible anyway."

(They are on permanent display, except when the Met loans them out.)

But why not a short-term loan so we could see them as they were intended to be viewed?

Cosmetatou paused and then said, "That would have been a good idea."

Had the institutions tried to work something out so all the plates could be seen together?

"I don't know," she said, but promised to get back to me.

Perhaps there's no one to admonish here unless a request by one or the other institution was made and turned down.  Could neither one have thought of it?

Photo of six David Plates at the Met, © 2011 Laura Gilbert

Other Photos: Head of Aphrodite and Personification of April, © Hellenic Ministry of Culture and Tourism; Marriage of David, © Cyprus Museum; icon fragment, © Benaki Museum; detail of David and Goliath from Metropolitan Museum website; mummy portrait from Walters Art Museum website.

Text © 2011 Laura Gilbert.